#9295. Evidence Use in Argument Writing Based on Multiple Texts

September 2026publication date
Proposal available till 29-05-2025
4 total number of authors per manuscript4500 $

The title of the journal is available only for the authors who have already paid for
Journal’s subject area:
Education;
Developmental and Educational Psychology;
Places in the authors’ list:
place 1place 2place 3place 4
FreeFreeFreeFree
1350 $1200 $1050 $900 $
Contract9295.1 Contract9295.2 Contract9295.3 Contract9295.4
1 place - free (for sale)
2 place - free (for sale)
3 place - free (for sale)
4 place - free (for sale)

Abstract:
In this study, we focused on one particular challenge in argumentative writing based on multiple texts: evidence use. Specifically, we first examined undergraduate students’ strategy reports when processing evidence presented in conflicting and comparably trustworthy texts. Both surface-level (i.e., restating) and deep-level (e.g., evaluation, elaboration) evidence-related processing strategies were identified in students’ typed strategy reports. Second, we examined students’ use of text-based evidence in their writing. Students were found to have limitations in both the quantity and quality of evidence use in writing. Finally, we associated students’ evidence-related processing strategies with their evidence use in writing. Only the quality of students’ evidence use in writing was significantly predicted by their evidence-related processing strategies. However, significant predictors of the quality of evidence use in writing included both surface- and deep-level strategies. Implications for instruction are discussed.
Keywords:
5-College / university; Assessment; Cognitive; Comprehension; Writing; Writing Argumentation

Contacts :
0